PECHORIN'S home   account   archive   eshop   globalmediapro
.
.


Post new message


Home | First message in thread | Previous message

Re: Re: Sony PD170 vs Panasonic DVX100a

angela Posted Jun 29, 2004, in response to:Steve Rosen

I went to the sundance film festival set on getting a pd170 after film friends/directors suggested that is what i should start on. But I was introduced to the panasonic agdvx100a 24p while I was their . i was told by other directors that that is the camra to get. So now my dilema is do I get the dvx100a or the pd170. What is the visual difference between the two. i want the best quality. I have a sony vx2000 and love the feel and I am use to the sony look. So aesthetically i am interested in the sony. But I am interested in better quality. What are the pros and cons of each?

Reply

Share |
1 comment

    Angela: I have a PD-150, a DSR-300 and (now) two DVX100As, as well as a super16 Aaton. I make my living with these cameras. I use the camera that I feel is most appropriate for the job. Sony cameras look like video, but good video, are definitely better made, feel more like quality cameras, and probably, as a result, last longer - I also like the robust DVCAM format - Ive literally never had a dropout with DVCAM. But the Panasonic takes great "film like" pictures after you learn to tweak it (it has considerable menu options and takes some dilligent testing to get it where you want it). As for quality, that is touchy because the Sonys appear to have better resolution, but the DVX has a better, softer "look", truly more like a film transfer (not 35mm Eastman though, don't let anyone fool you - more like ASA 200 16mm Fuji). It's also much better in the "squeeze mode" if 16x9 is an issue. Everyone in these chat rooms has a "this is better, that is worse" attitude depending on the camera they own. Since I own both, like them all for different reasons, I can only suggest that you look at footage from the 2 cameras and pick the one that fits your visual philosophy or your intended project(s) - it's really subjective. Steve Rosen

    Reply




  


© 2001-2012 - Pechorin's - Contact Us - Report a bug

Pechorin's does not take responsibility for the content of the messages published in the Forum.

RSS feed